1. Curran

    Another great blog Alyx! But, you missed the “original”: Michelle Shocked’s “On the Greener Side” from 1990 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J1NyTN3FG9s). It’s a deliberate satire/feminist critique of the Palmer video, from self-described feminist Shocked (who is also a UT grad). The Shania video is somewhat of a rip off, or rather a double rip-off. Although, Shocked’s version is more loose in its interpretation.

  2. Curran

    You’re welcome! The video got a good deal of airplay on MTV back in the/my day and the Palmer parody was duly noted. As you can imagine, in those pre-Marky-Mark-in-Calvin-Kleins days the video’s blatant objectification of the male body was seen as unusual, which is, of course, the point: to satirize the objectification of women in Palmer’s video and music videos more generally by “turning the tables.” The video was significant enough that it was, in fact, nominated for best female video of the year, along with Paula Abdul — “Opposites Attract,” Madonna — “Vogue,” Alannah Myles — “Black Velvet,” and Sinead O’Connor — “Nothing Compares 2 U,” — Sinead won, as she did for best video of the year. Ah, memories – I was an MTV junkie back then!

  3. Annie Petersen

    Man, I used to listen to ‘Greener Side’ ALL THE TIME — my mom was a huge Michelle Shocked fan, as was I — and, because MTV was a no-go in my household, had NO IDEA of any layering connotations.

  4. Ange

    People fail to realize that the video wasn’t Palmer’s concept at all and in fact, he was actually turned off by the girls that dressed that way at his later shows (Peep the vintage 1988 GQ inverview over at http://robert-palmer.over-blog.com/). RP rarely lived up to the image that the music industry made for him. 🙂 I also think that more than anything, the videos were send-ups of the old Benny Hill “Sexy Party” sketches to begin with.

  5. Pingback: Korean Sociological Image #29: JYP and the Objectification of Women « The Grand Narrative
  6. joe

    Benny Hill? now there ‘s a party
    I like the versions by Michelle Shocked, Shania, and all the others. These are all tributes to musical/video talent!!
    why criticise when we can contribute?

    I want to meet a Robert Palmer girl !!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s